Ranking all 32 NFL general managers based on leaked NFLPA report card grades: Giants at the bottom

March 7, 2026 - 00:28

A confidential report card compiled by the NFL Players Association has been made public, offering a rare glimpse into how players themselves rank the performance of all 32 general managers. The survey, which polled over 1,700 players on workplace conditions, included direct feedback on the leadership of each team's top football executive.

The results reveal significant disparities in player satisfaction across the league. While some front offices received high marks for communication, respect, and roster investment, others faced sharp criticism. The New York Giants' general manager, Joe Schoen, found his organization at the very bottom of the overall rankings, indicating a substantial disconnect between the front office and the locker room according to the players surveyed.

The report card grades general managers on several key criteria, including their perceived willingness to invest in team facilities, the efficiency of the travel schedule, and the overall treatment of players' families. This player-driven data provides an unconventional but powerful metric for evaluating front-office effectiveness, moving beyond wins and losses to assess the day-to-day working environment. The leak is expected to prompt internal discussions within several franchises, particularly those that scored poorly, as player morale and retention are critical components of long-term success. The findings underscore that a general manager's job extends far beyond the draft board and salary cap, deeply impacting the culture and professional experience of the athletes.